Learning from Giants' Mistakes in Cataract Surgery Fedorov 67 vs Fyodorov 75
Samir I Sayegh, MD, PhD, FACS, FAAO, FASRS
Click here to view the paper.
One of the most influential papers in the history of cataract surgery is Fedorov and Kolinko’s 1967 paper. All so called third and fourth generation intraocular lens calculation formulas implemented to this day are based on it. We show that the actual expression given in the 1967 article is incorrect and was subsequently corrected by Fedorov and colleagues in 1975. We show the source of error and comment on implications for modern day intraocular power calculations for cataract surgery.
Slava Fedorov’s contributions to Ophthalmology are profound and lasting. In a paper with Albina Kolinko in 1967 they attempted a rational theoretical approach to the computation of intraocular lens (IOL) power based on biometry of the patient’s eye1. The paper was written in Russian and was followed by a few similar attempts by mainly European ophthalmologists. In 1975, together with Galin and Linksz, Fedorov (Fyodorov) contributed a similar article and computation to the English literature2. This made the approach more accessible to a wider readership and was followed by the (re)introduction of regression methods exemplified by SRK3,4 and somewhat later, by a realization that theoretical methods were foundational and need be adopted albeit with a grain of tweaking! This is represented by some of the major “third generation” or “vergence based” formulas such as Holladay1, SRKT and HofferQ5,6,7, all of which cite at least one of the Fyodorov and colleague’s papers and are in turn some of the most cited and implemented papers in the IOL power calculation literature. To our knowledge, there is no systematic comparison that has been attempted between the 1967 and 1975 versions of Fedorov and colleagues’ articles. In fact, a number of papers have cited both the 1967 and 1975 articles without mention of any discrepancy4,6,8. Others will cite only one9 or the other3,10,11. Some will mention a date and cite the article from the other date12. Yet others, surprisingly, cite neither13. In the present work we start by a direct comparison of the key formulas and their differences including numeric estimates and clinical implications. We follow with an analysis of the original sources and the sources of errors and draw conclusions as to lessons to be learned.
To address the global threat posed by diabetes, World Diabetes Day was established with the support of the World Health Organization (WHO) by the International Diabetes Federation in 1991. This date marks the birthday of Dr. Fredrick Banting, a co-discoverer of insulin. The 2022 theme is Access to Diabetes Care. One in 10 adults is living with diabetes and according to the WHO, close to 1 million are blind due to diabetic retinopathy. As the number of people with diabetes continues to rise, particularly in low- and middle-income countries, so too does the need for access to high-quality diabetes eye care. The ICO is in Official Relations with the WHO and promotes the key role of the ophthalmology community and those they work with in realizing the targets to increase eye-care coverage around the world.
Free Online Low Vision Seminars
The AFB (American Foundation for the Blind) recently referenced a report from Vision Serve Alliance that says only 3% of those who could benefit from low vision care actually get that care. The reasons vary, but among them are the reluctance, difficulty or inability of patients to go to a low vision practitioner due to the pandemic, distance or transportation issues.
With Eschenbach’s telelowvision program, you can overcome all of those obstacles and reach those patients by conducting a virtual appointment and provide them the care they need!
Would you like to know more about Low Vision without the hassles and costs of traveling to a conference? Eschenbach Optik of America provides free webinars on a variety of Low Vision topics that you can view and listen!
Wednesday, November 16, 2022 at 3pm Eastern, "Pediatric Low Vision: Determining which strategies and devices work best for your pediatric patients!"
Speaker: Dr. Thomas Porter, Director of Low Vision Services, Saint Louis University, Department of Ophthalmology. Approved for ACVREP credit. Click here to register.
… and where in the world is Dr. Sayegh?
So much is a part of our Eye Center family’s eye-centered world. From cutting edge research and world-wide presentations to the concerns and issues faced by our clients (and clients-to-be!). Here is where you will find the latest and greatest, and as always, if you have a concern or question, don’t hesitate to call and ask. We want for you the best vision your eyes can have!